By Vic MacDonald | Regional Editor
The presiding judge in disgraced attorney Alex Murdaugh's double-murder re-trial said on Friday that the original indictments are sufficient for the April re-trial, necessary after the SC Supreme Court threw out his conviction for shooting to death his wife and son in 2021.
That means that The State will not have to come back to the Colleton County Grand Jury, which convenes in Walterboro, for new indictments. The Grand Jury handed down indictments in 2022. The Murdaugh defense said these indictments are flawed, for several reasons including allegedly mistaken testimony of a SLED agent; but the lead defense counsel did not comment Friday on Judge Debra McCaslin's ruling. The SC Attorney General's Office said, in a statement, "We continue to prepare for the retrial in April."
That will happen in Sumter, as Judge McCaslin already has ruled that potential Colleton County jurors could not give once-prominent attorney Murdaugh a fair trial, the second time around.
The judge said that the SLED agent's not presenting a full and accurate picture of some evidence, including blood spatter, did not rise to the level of "bad faith misconduct" and, thus, did not warrant the dismissal of the indictments.
McCaslin issued an 11-page ruling. She had said at a Nov. 13 pre-trial hearing that she would decide the Defense's motion by Nov. 20 with a written order. Defense Attorney Jim Griffin told the judge at the Nov. 13 hearing that Murdaugh and the defense were looking for a "reboot" and to send the murder case "back to square one". Instead, McCaslin said, even with some challenged evidence, some other evidence would show "overwhelmingly established probable cause" to have the Colleton County Grand Jury indict Murdaugh.
Murdaugh is serving federal and state time for financial crimes, to which he has admitted his guilt.
However, he has steadfastly denied shooting his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, to death on June 7, 2021, at the family's rural Colleton County estate; the murder weapons have not yet been found.
McCaslin indicated that it would have taken "extraordinary circumstances" to justify granting the Defense motion for the indictments dismissal. The Defense was not asking for the case to be thrown out all together; but for The State to have to re-present it to the grand jury with acknowledgement that some evidence was in dispute.
The ruling keeps the Murdaugh re-trial on schedule for April 5, in Sumter, a timetable that Judge McCaslin has indicated she is anxious to keep in tact.